Quiet Title Claim
A Claim or action to quiet title is a lawsuit brought in a court
having jurisdiction over land disputes, in order to establish a party's
title to real property against anyone and everyone, and thus "quiet" any
challenges or claims to the title. The basic element is a complaint that
the ownership (title) of a parcel of land or other real property is
defective in some fashion, typically where title to the property is
ambiguous. A typical ground for complaint includes the fraudulent
conveyance of a property, perhaps by a forged deed or other documents, or
the borrower/victim was under coercion,
adverse possession,
Fraud or Deception or simply
to remove a
lien or other encumbrance, etc.
.
We
will focus on the issues as it could relate to foreclosure defense and a
Homeowner taking an "offensive approach" to defending their legal rights
of ownership.
A quiet
title claim is also called a quiet title suit to remove a cloud. A cloud is any
claim or potential claim to ownership of the property. I.e.: a Foreclosure
Action. The cloud can be a claim of full ownership of the property or a
claim of partial ownership, such as a lien in an amount that does not
exceed the value of the property. A title to real property is clouded if
the plaintiff, as the buyer or recipient of real estate, might have to
defend her full ownership of the property in court against some party in
the future. A landowner may bring a quiet title action regardless of
whether the respondent is asserting a present right to gain possession of
the premises.
If the
court finds that the party petitioning for quiet title actually owns the
title, the court will grant a quiet title judgment, providing that the
party has legal and good title. A quiet title judgment may and should then
be recorded in the county recorder's office.
An action
for quiet title or remove a cloud on the title serves to cure and perfect
legal title to real property. The action is an equitable remedy and often
falls within the jurisdiction of the circuit courts. The two major
classifications of quiet title actions are (1) quasi in rem actions, and
(2) actions to quiet tax titles.
The law on quiet title
actions varies from state to state. Some states have quiet title statutes.
Other states allow courts to fashion most of the laws regarding quiet
title actions. Under the COMMON LAW;, a
plaintiff must be in possession of the property to bring a quiet title
action, but many state statutes do not require actual possession by the
plaintiff.
Quiet
Title Claim as a Foreclosure Offense
The impact in foreclosure
OFFENSE is that the loan has been assigned, sold and transferred multiple
times and broken up into thousands of pieces along with many others that
were intermingled in portfolios, sometimes with cross guarantees from one
portfolio to another.
This process was initiated
before the first payment was due on the mortgage loan and before the
borrower came to know the real facts of the loan withheld from him,
therefore the true owner, against whom rescission could be claimed, became
unknown to the homeowner/borrower. The quiet title action sues all “John
Does” identified as all possible persons having an ownership interest in
the mortgage lien on the subject property. The allegation is made that
while the victim/borrower has been notified of a transaction, the
victim/borrower; petitioner has not been advised of who the entities or
people are who own this interest.
Believe it or not,
In some states
possession is not applicable. In some states only the person who holds
legal title to the real estate may file a quiet title action, but in other
states anyone with satisfactory interest in the property may bring a quiet
title action. Generally, a person who has sold the property does not have
sufficient interest. When a landowner owns property subject to a mortgage,
the landowner may bring a quiet title action in states where the mortgagor
retains title to the property. If the mortgagee keeps the title until the
mortgage is paid, the mortgagee, not the landowner, would have to bring
the action.
The general rule in a quiet
title action is that the plaintiff may be successful only on the strength
of his own claim to the real estate, and not on the weakness of the
respondent's claim. The plaintiff bears the burden of proving that he owns
the title to the property. A plaintiff may have less than a fee simple, or
less than full ownership, and maintain an action to quiet title. So long
as the plaintiff's interest is valid and the respondent's interest is not,
the plaintiff will be successful in removing the cloud (the respondent's
claim) from the title to the property.
In many
states there is a statutory recognition to the power of a court of equity
to consider actions to determine title, quiet it to the rightful owner,
and grant incidental relief. They provide for removing clouds from titles
in proceedings that may be brought by any person or corporation,
whether or not in actual possession, that claims legal or equitable
title to real estate against any person or corporation that, although not
in actual possession, either has or appears to have or claim an adverse
legal or equitable estate, interest, or claim in the real estate.
Relief may
be granted even though the title has not been litigated at law and despite
the existence of only one litigant to each side of the controversy. Relief
is also provided even though the adverse claim, estate, or interest is
void on its face or requires evidence extrinsic to the claim itself to
establish its validity. Actions may be brought in the name of the current
owner or prior owners who may have warranted the title involved.
Source:
Roger H Staley J.D.
Quasi in
rem refers to a legal action which mainly involves property rights, but
partly involves personal rights as well. A quasi in rem action
determines the rights of a person in a thing. It deals with the rights
of specific individuals in a thing, rather than the rights of the world
in a thing.
For example, foreclosing
a mortgage is a quasi in rem action because it seeks not to determine
the rights of the world in a piece of property, but rather, the rights
between the lender and the borrower. There might be others who could have
interests too. Generally, a quasi in rem action tries to secure a
preexisting claim in the property, or extinguish someone else's. In some
cases, it may be used to substitute for personal jurisdiction, where a
defendant’s property is applied to satisfy a claim that is unrelated to
property.
Attorneys
often become involved with serious title problems before they discover
that a quiet title action is necessary. This is sometimes considered an
unwelcome by-product of the attorney’s real property practice. Regardless
of whether attorneys drift into the litigation in this manner or know at
the time of first contact with a client that a quiet title action is
needed, it is extremely important for attorneys to advise their clients as
early as possible regarding the extent and cost of title litigation.
Obviously
there are procedural and time considerations involved in statutory quiet
title actions as well as non-statutory jurisdiction and alternative
actions to settle title questions such as the possibility of ejectment
* ejectment :
a lawsuit brought to remove a party who is occupying real property.
This is not the same as an unlawful detainer (eviction) suit against a
non-paying or unsatisfactory tenant. It is against someone who has tried
to claim title to the property
Quiet
Title and Rescission as another
Possible
Foreclosure Offense
Consider this as an
offensive procedure, the Quiet title Action is based upon the supposition
that the lender assigned or transferred or sold the mortgage and note
right after the closing on your contract. Logically then the person to
whom you would address your TILA, fraud, and deceptive and unfair
practices claims would be addressed to the new owner of the mortgage and
note. The problem is: with the securitization of mortgages into trusts and
Mortgage Backed Securities, Who really owns the note? If your Forensic
Loan Audit done properly, and a certified Qualified Written Request (QWR)
was executed, the documents requested are usually ignored by the servicers
and everyone else the QWR was sent.
U.S. Lender AuditTM
is the National leading provider of Forensic Loan AuditingSM services
to Law Firms, Attorneys, Non Profit Organizations, Loan
Modification Companies, Servicers, Hedge Funds, and Borrowers. U.S.
Lender Audit services a team of expert auditors that have been conducting
forensic mortgage loan audits and compliance audits as a niche company for
nearly a decade. Using traditional manual forensics, thoroughly
investigated by
hand, U.S. Lender Audit's industry experts provide the most
accurate and comprehensive loan audit available in today's market,
capturing ALL
violations made prior to or at closing, guaranteed. No other
Forensic Loan AuditingSM servicer provides a more
complete and accurate examination with
it's rapid turn-around time, and
100% money back guarantee. And, if no
violations are found, we will issue a full refund, no questions asked!
Forensic Loan Audit
We know from the Forensic
Loan Audit that there are TILA and other fraudulent violations, then the
victim/ borrower/petitioner wishes to rescind. All the hard work to
determine the true owners have led the Petitioner to determine that there
may be thousands of entities or owners, none of whom have been disclosed
despite attempts to secure said information (contained in the Forensic
Loan Audit and QWR).
Quiet Title can an
operation of law after rescission. In essence the reverse of a traditional
foreclosure where the owner of the property forecloses the claim of the
people against whom he has filed suit claiming the property free and clear
of all encumbrances.
Quiet
Title Service Of Process Is By Publication
To initiate
an action to quiet title, the property owner must do all of the following
in their local Court:
-
Identify the legal description of the property to be "quieted".
- Name
any entity who might have an interest in the described property as a
defendant to the lawsuit, and include supporting facts why they have a
claim.
- Best
Efforts to provide Notice must be given to all potentially interested
parties.
A possible scenario an
attorney could face is the court might demand that the mortgage
servicing company be named as nominal Defendant or Respondent. I this
scenario, the mortgage servicing company has only one job: to produce
information and proof of ownership of the loan. It is doubtful that
anyone, least of all the mortgage servicer can satisfy this condition.
Since the demands for proof
of ownership can not be shown by the other side, a default judgment can
and should be entered, the borrower stops paying the mortgage. There would
then be a recorded judgment relieving his property of any mortgage lien
and offsetting the note with the refunds and damages due to the homeowner
thus satisfying the entire principal of the note and awarding attorney
fees to the homeowner who filed the Quiet Title Claim.
A quiet title claim is a claim brought by a plaintiff to establish his or
her claim or right to land by forcing an adverse claimant to prove their
claim or be prohibited from ever bringing a claim.
Quiet Title Calim and
Qualified Written Requests
Keep in mind, the Lenders/ Servicers have
20 business days per the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA) to
respond to the written request and 60 business days to try and settle this
matter. In the event the Lender does not act within the timeframe's listed
above, you may file "Documented Mortgage Complaints" to all appropriate
local, state and federal regulatory agencies, as the servicer would be in
serious default!
A "Quiet Title" cause of action is a type of lawsuit claim that is
filed by a litigant in order to decide who has the superior right or claim
to title of a parcel of real property. The purpose of the quiet title
action is to establish who has superior legal or equitable title, and to
establish title against adverse claims.
The definition from Black's law dictionary is "
A proceeding to establish the plaintiff's
title to land by bringing into court, an adverse claimant and there
compelling him either to establish his claim or be forever after estopped
from asserting it. "
Quiet title cases arise in many different fact situations.
The most common situations are as follows:
1) The true owner was the victim of a fraud by a forgery of a title
instrument. Or adverse possession, This typically involves the forgery
of a deed that is recorded in the County. The quiet title action is
filed to restore the title to the true owner.
2) There is a tax defaulted property that has been purchased at a tax
sale, and all subsequent taxes levied and payable have been paid, the
purchaser or any person claiming through the purchaser may bring an
action to determine adverse claims to or clouds upon the property.
U.S. Lender Audit provides the most flexible and accurate outsource
Forensic Loan AuditTM solution and litigation
support available anywhere for organizations and attorneys seeking
litigation opportunities and work-out plans for their clients. Our
mortgage audit service and expert auditors provide thorough manual
forensics examinations capturing violations NO SOFTWARE can catch!!!
Additionally, the company reverse engineers all loan parameters, so
ALL VIOLATIONS of Federal, State, County and
Municipal Code are revealed along their severity and the specific
code in violation. The result of our mortgage audit services is
a detailed comprehensive analysis that reveals
ALL RESPA,
TILA,
HOEPA,
ECOA,
GLB, FDCPA Violations and More in an easy-to-read format. All
infractions of State Lending Fairness Guidelines and
Predatory Lending laws are applied.
Sample Forensic Mortgage Compliance Audit
Our
loan audit and its supportive findings provides a common ground where
all parties can understand such violations that are evident along
with proposed observations of preliminary suspect whereby
a valid motion or demand for further discovery presents itself with
clarity. Position your clients in an offensive position to where proper
remediation is scalable. The U.S. Lender Audit provides you
with the evidence and support you can trust to help your clients seek
better modification terms, restructuring of new terms, principal or rate
reduction, or continued discovery. With the greatest potential to
alleviate "normal modification" setbacks and re-occurrence of default,
qualified and objective evidence helps simplify
negotiations and stay using the information and support provided
by U.S. Lender Audit.
Let us demonstrate the REAL
difference of the
U.S. Lender Audit's Forensic Loan Audit
versus other companies reporting methodologies. No other report
shows the specifics like we do, providing thorough ACCURACY and the
EVIDENCE, and designed so that you know what is REAL and what is Potential
Violations, based on how the information provided to us were obtained.
The difference of knowing what is evidence and what is suspect is
imperative for next steps! Ask to be invited to our FREE
regularly scheduled online forums, where we show you ALL the specifics to
better understand why we are the "Most
Trusted and Reliable Loan Audit Company" in the industry!
In Closing there are many other factual situations that pertain to quiet
title actions. In each of these situations, the burden of proof is on
the plaintiff to prove his or her case. The burden of proof is on the
defendant to prove his defense. In the quiet title lawsuit, the plaintiff
usually files a lis pendens. The lis pendens is a notice that is
recorded in the County where the real property is located. The notice is
served on all parties to the lawsuit, and is file in the Court where the
action is pending.
The key is that Quiet Title Claim and the resulting actions are always
decided by judges, and are not tried by juries. and this is where US
Lender Audit litigation support can help you in case management and
structure, allowing you, the attorney more time to litigate and WIN!
.The
other importance of the mortgage audit findings is that it may be the
grounds to help move a non-judicial foreclosure action (currently in 29
states), if necessary, into jurisdiction, which can STOP FORECLOSURE in
its tracks. More importantly, borrowers regardless of financial hardship
and payment history now have the chance for a better position to negotiate
new terms or loan settlement. Violations found in a loan audit can help
place the borrower in the offense! U.S. Lender Audit helps legal
professionals navigate through the process with our learning
channels, which we find critical for those legal advisors that are looking
to make the audit solution part of their business practice. Information
is only as good as the ones that know how best to use it. Let U.S. Lender
Audit demonstrate our unparalleled litigation support for your firm
today! Contact us now to get started with a private consultation or
orientation from our team of specialists.
U.S. Lender Audit
provides the
Nation's #1, MOST Comprehensive and
Accurate Forensic Loan AnalysisTM
identifying EVERY
fraud or misrepresentations made by lender, appraiser, broker, loan
officers, processors, and more!
Call Toll Free:
888-8-AUDITING or 888-828-3484
Servicing All 50 states!
The information presented on this Web site is
not to be construed as legal advice. Legal advice must be tailored to the
specific circumstances of each case. Every effort has been made to assure
that this information is up-to-date as of the date of publication. It is
not intended to be a full and exhaustive explanation of the law in any
area. This information is not intended as legal advice and may not be used
as legal advice. It should not be used to replace the advice of your own
legal counsel. Especially if
you are considering a Quiet
Title Claim, Quiet Title Filing or Quiet Title
Foreclosure Offense
Disclaimer
Copyright © 2008.
U.S. Lender Audit,
LLC. All Rights Reserved.
|